George Herbert Mead
What are the processes that George Herbert Mead argues links the personal to the external?
He argued that we must become self-conscious, we must look from the outside looking in so that we could see ourselves from others perspectives. An example giving is a person who is going to a job interview and faces the dilemma of formality v comfort. If he dresses smart he faces the risk of been too hot and looking uncomfortable, he knows this by looking at himself from how the interviewer would see him, thus linking the personal to the external.
What is Mead referring to when he uses the term ‘symbolizing’?
‘Identities are produced in a social context, but through individuals thinking about what links them to the social world’, words, pictures, images and gestures all act as symbols. We use these to create a particular identity for contextual reasons. For example a man wearing a suit to an interview, the suit signifies a candidate serious about earning the job available.
What is happening when we ‘visualise’ ourselves?
We visualise ourselves within scenarios, for an example the job interview, a person may be feeling pessimistic and visualises the interview going terrible, being in a hot environment and uncomfortable. Or a person may be feeling optimistic, visualising the interview going great and feeling confident you’ll get the job.
How do we ‘signal’ our identities to others?
Within the production of identities, symbols and representations are very important; they are what signal our identities to others. It is how we recognize each other’s identities, and distinguish them, through how we speak and what we chose to wear.
What ‘choice’ does Judith Williamson argue that we have?
She states that every morning we are faced with a choice, the choice to chose what we will wear and what identity we will be seen as for the day. She states that the choice we make tends to exclude other possible identities as a item of clothing has certain connotations. For example a leather skirt, this kind of skirt rules out an identity of innocence gives her an identity relating to sexual themes. She also says that is both gives and takes freedom, she has different identities she can wear, but choosing one will come with set connotations, she cannot wear something for the leisure of it.
How do Mead’s and Williamson’s arguments develop our understanding of identity?
Their arguments about the approach to the notion of identity put more emphasis on the control individuals have rather than the constraints which they experience. To an extent we have the freedom to choose how we will be seen by others; we do this through symbolizing ourselves. We decide how we want to be seen, whether it is through a occasion such as an interview or just what we chose to wear in the morning.
Erving Goffman
What conclusions does Erving Goffman reach in his analysis of everyday interaction, conversations and encounters? What theoretical argument does he offer as a result?
He suggests that the way we present ourselves to others, is like acting out a part to a play where the scripts are already written. He refers to roles instead of identities but it can be linked to identities through his discussion of everyday interaction and how we present ourselves. He states in his book ‘The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life (1959)’ that what we are is not given to us but must be created and that we act out many different roles as if in a play.
How is Goffman’s ‘presentation of self’ different from ‘investing in an identity’?
Goffman believes ‘presentations of self’ is that some people act the part for particular reasons, a student must portray themselves in a way for their tutors, they must look earnest, submit work on time and work hard in lessons. The same with a doctor or teacher, they are important people and must present themselves specifically, for the sake of others. Whereas ‘investing in an identity’ is having a personal investment in an identity, this does give us more detail to read people and a message about ‘who they are.’
Not all our actions are conscious or explicit. What is the consequence of this?
The consequence is that we may be playing a particular role, but unconsciously we give messages to contradict our roles. For example the person in an interview will be playing a confident candidate but may be twisting their fingers, conveying to the interviewer of their anxiety and thus breaking their role. Or a friend may be pretending to be interested listening to someone but unintentionally looks around and tapping their fingers, showing they are bored.
How do Goffman’s arguments develop our understanding of the social dimensions of identity and the relationship between identity and roles?
His emphasis is on the social dimensions of identity and the relationship between identity, with its concern with social investment, and roles which tell us more about the social aspects and social exchanges between people. His approach suggests there are links between society in which we live and the limitations offered by the roles we play. But there is a scope for agency because those who play the parts can improvise and offer their own interpretation.
Freudian
What is the Freudian unconscious?
The unconscious is a idea that had passed into everyday language in Western societies through popular culture, the advertising industry and through psychoanalytically inspired practices like therapy. There is a idea known as ‘Freudian Slips’ this is where we say a word which is not the word we intended to say, which gives a person an idea of their unconscious mind. An example is given that in a essay someone wrote ‘of coffee’ instead of ‘of course’, by saying coffee their unconscious mind may be saying they want a break from writing. Freud argued that these slips, along with joke and dream, show our ‘true’ feelings.
How according to Freud does identity emerge?
As children we repress all our anti-social needs and wants, this enters our unconscious mind and is revealed through slips of the tongue and dreams. Who we are is not given in advance but it emerges in a number of different forms, so we don’t have on fixed, coherent identity but have several in play.
What is signified by the term ‘identification’ when used in the context of psychoanalysis?
Identification does not just involve copying but it is to take a identity into yourself, for example male children are interested with their fathers although they love their mothers they aspire to grow up like their fathers and take their place.
What impact can sex, sexuality and gender have on identity?
Freud argues that sexuality is our most important psychological drive; by sexuality he means a broad range of pleasure-seeking desires which are experienced even by newborn babies, who for example derive pleasure from sucking. He argues that if the child’s needs are met during infancy, then they will grow up with a positive outlook on life, whereas the children’s needs, who are not me, grow up to be more pessimistic. Overall Freud says that these desires are repressed into the unconscious mind and ultimately affect your identity.
What implications do Freud’s theories have for our exploration of identity?
Freud’s theories give us an understanding of the processes at work in the formation of identities. It suggests that even childhood experiences we are not even conscious of can have a affect on the decisions we make as a adult, indication we have limited control over the identities we take up. He says that we can come into understanding of those things we have repressed into our unconscious mind through methods such as therapy.
No comments:
Post a Comment